Interview Mastery
Why qualified directors get rejected—and how to win competitive pharma roles.
⏱️ Read time: 5 minutes
⚡ TL;DR – The 3 Things That Matter
- Your resume gets scored by ATS before humans see it. Customize every resume to match the exact role requirements.
- Quantify everything. “Launched a product” scores lower than “Led $120M launch achieving 23% market share in 12 months.”
- STAR+I: The “I” (Insight) is what wins. Show what you learned and will bring to the new role—this separates you from 199 other qualified candidates.
The Wake-Up Call
My resume was rejected for a Director of Marketing role despite having 7 years of HCP marketing experience.
Why? Because my last two roles were in Medical Affairs. The hiring manager never saw past my recent titles. The ATS flagged me as “not a marketing fit.”
That’s when I learned: Your resume isn’t about what you’ve done. It’s about what the ATS and hiring manager are looking for.
The Brutal Truth About Pharma Director Interviews
You’re not competing against 5 candidates. You’re competing against 200+ displaced directors with similar credentials.
Generic interview advice won’t cut it. Here’s what actually works:
System 1: Master the ATS Game
💡 AHA MOMENT: ATS Uses Machine Learning to Score You
ATS systems like Workday don’t just scan for keywords. They use machine learning to compare your profile to candidates who were successful in similar roles.
What gets scored:
- Education match (MBA? PhD? Relevant certifications?)
- Previous company profiles (Big Pharma vs. Biotech vs. CRO)
- Functional experience depth (years in marketing, medical, etc.)
- Therapeutic area alignment
- Skills match (rare disease, oncology, launch, digital, etc.)
Real example: I was applying for a role that required “proven rare disease launch leadership experience.” I didn’t have rare disease experience, but I had extensive launch leadership. My resume scored ~65% because of that gap. I got the interview anyway because I positioned my launch experience as indispensable and handled the rare disease gap during the interview. Learn the indispensable vs. handleable framework →
✅ Action Step: Know Your Score Before Applying
Read the job description and ask yourself:
- Indispensable: What does the hiring team absolutely need? (e.g., launch experience, therapeutic area, function)
- Handleable: What gaps can you address in the interview? (e.g., rare disease, specific vendor experience)
Rule of thumb: Only apply if you have 80%+ of the indispensable requirements. Otherwise, you’re wasting time.
💡 AHA MOMENT: Quantify Everything
The #1 way ATS and hiring managers evaluate your success is by measuring your previous success. If you can’t quantify it, it didn’t happen.
Bad: “Led product launch and managed cross-functional teams.”
Good: “Led $120M product launch achieving 23% market share in 12 months, managing 15-person cross-functional team across Marketing, Medical, and Market Access.”
Every achievement needs a metric: Revenue, market share, % growth, team size, timeline, budget, patient outcomes, etc. See 20 examples of quantified pharma achievements →
System 2: Design Your Resume Like a Weapon
💡 AHA MOMENT: Customize Every Resume
If you have a broad profile (multiple functions, geographies, or therapeutic areas), using one generic resume will destroy your chances.
Why it matters: Hiring managers make snap judgments. If your last role was Medical Affairs but you’re applying for Marketing, they’ll assume you’re “not a marketer” even if you have 7 years of marketing experience.
The fix: Reorganize your resume to lead with the experience that matches the role. For a Marketing role, lead with your marketing achievements. For a Medical role, lead with your medical achievements.
💡 AHA MOMENT: Target Roles Where You Have ALL Required Skills
I noticed I’m getting invited for Director Marketing roles significantly more now than 2 years ago—despite my last marketing role being 4+ years ago.
What changed? Two things:
- I completed my MBA (matches “MBA required” on 80% of Director roles)
- I gained recent launch experience (the #1 requirement for pharma marketing directors)
Strategic takeaway: Look at the “required or highly preferred” section. If you’re missing 2+ items, you’re probably wasting your time. Focus on roles where you check all the boxes.
💡 AHA MOMENT: Target Growth Therapeutic Areas
I purposely targeted oncology and immunology experiences in the past few years. Why? Because that’s where the jobs are.
Strategic career positioning: Don’t just take any role. Take roles that build credentials in high-demand therapeutic areas. This compounds your marketability over time.
System 3: Deliver Executive Presence in Interviews
💡 AHA MOMENT: STAR+I = The “I” Is What Wins
Use proper STAR+I responses for situational interview questions. But here’s what most directors miss: the “I” (Insight) is what separates you from the other 199 candidates.
Without conciseness: You’re perceived as lacking executive presence.
Without Insight: Your experience seems transactional, not transformational.
The STAR+I Framework:
- Situation: Context in 1-2 sentences
- Task: Your specific responsibility
- Action: What you did (focus on YOUR actions, not “we”)
- Result: Quantified outcome
- Insight: What you learned and will take to your next role—this is what makes you indispensable
Why Insight wins: Anyone can deliver results. But showing that you extracted a transferable learning that you’ll bring to the new role? That’s what makes hiring managers say “we need this person.” It demonstrates self-awareness, growth mindset, and strategic thinking.
Example Insight: “This experience taught me that cross-functional alignment on forecasting assumptions upfront prevents downstream firefighting. In my next role, I’ll establish this as a standard practice in the first 30 days of any launch.” See 5 pharma-specific STAR+I examples →
💡 AHA MOMENT: Mine Your Experience Deeply
I used to use the same 3-4 examples in every interview. Then I used generative AI (Claude) to run deep conversational analysis of my experience.
What I discovered: I had forgotten examples that were 10x more compelling than the ones I’d been using for years. I found instances where I was the key force behind major successes—not just a contributor.
The exercise: Ask yourself (or ask AI): “Why was that a success? What was MY specific contribution? What would have happened if I hadn’t been there?”
This critical thinking uncovers the gold you’ve been sitting on. Learn how to use AI to mine your experience →
💡 AHA MOMENT: Position as Leader, Not Executor
Executive presence is about leading and guiding more than executing small business tasks.
Look deeply at what the role expects you to do and position yourself accordingly. If the job description says “strategic leadership” but your answers focus on tactical execution, you’ll lose to someone who frames their experience strategically.
Frame shift: Don’t say “I built the forecast model.” Say “I designed the forecasting framework that enabled the commercial team to adjust strategy quarterly, resulting in $15M in avoided waste.” See 10 language shifts for executive presence →
⚠️ Special Note for ADHD Professionals
If you have ADHD or English is not your first language, achieving conciseness in interviews is significantly harder. Executive functions and working memory challenges can make it difficult to deliver crisp, structured answers under pressure. Practice is non-negotiable. Record yourself answering questions, review for conciseness, and refine. Consider working with a coach who understands neurodiversity in pharma. Learn more about ADHD-specific interview strategies →
🚀 The Secret Weapon: Activate Your Senior Connections
Everything I’ve shared matters. But here’s the truth: a powerful senior connection who trusts you and knows you’d be a great hire is worth more than all of the above combined.
If you have VPs, SVPs, or C-suite executives in your network who know your work—activate them. A referral from the right person bypasses ATS, gets your resume to the top of the pile, and gives you an unfair advantage.
The 48-Hour Pre-Interview Prep Checklist
You got the interview. Now make every minute count:
The Bottom Line
You don’t need to be the best candidate. You need to be the candidate whose resume gets scored highest by the ATS, whose experience maps exactly to what they’re looking for, and who shows executive presence in every answer.
🎁 Get the Complete Interview Mastery Toolkit
Download the full guide with ATS optimization templates, 5 annotated resume examples, and the 48-hour prep checklist.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. I send frameworks, not fluff.